Episodes

Dec. 9, 2025

New! Unidentified--Willem and I visit Area 51

We put J Allen's story to bed, and begin our exploration of the most mysterious stretch of desert on earth, Area 51. This time, we learn what happened when show artist Willem UFO and I visited Rachel Nevada, the wide spot in ...

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 25, 2025

New! Unidentified--Hynek vs Sagan--two men enter, one man leave

How Mr. Billions repeatedly embarrassed our hero J Allen

Listen to the Episode
Nov. 11, 2025

New! Unidentified--The UFO, the coeds, and the swamp gas

This time, we explore perhaps the biggest UFO case of Dr. Hynek's career, which involved some farmers, some college students, and what in Dana Unicorn's words we might refer to as "marsh farts". Enjoy. Sorry for the brief hia...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 30, 2025

Unidentified--Sorry! The alien was behind door number 3

J Allen Hynek and the Monty Hall problem

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 16, 2025

New! Unidentified--Troy McClure and the Close Encounters Man

See! We told you! Non-abduction content.

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 2, 2025

New! Unidentified--Art Bell, John Mack, and Whitley Strieber

We're finished with abductions! No, for real!

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 19, 2025

New! Unidentified--Alien Abductions and Art Bell

As we wrap the science portion, we also stop into the High Desert, the Kingdom of Nye--in other words, we clip some classic Art Bell episodes to explore how Budd Hopkins promulgated his stories--including the Linda/Manhattan ...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 5, 2025

New! Unidentified--Maury says the alien IS the daddy...abductees and …

Maybe after all of this abduction talk, you've wondered what real scientists have to say about people being taken aboard alien spacecraft. And specifically, what to make of all of their reports of forced reproduction and alie...

Listen to the Episode
July 22, 2025

New! Unidentified--So, what really happened with that Manhattan alien…

Oops! Forgot to upload the episode. In this one, we get the denoument of the Budd Hopkins Manhattan alien abduction story. Next time, we hear from more skeptical, but still sympathetic, researchers who have examined abduction...

Listen to the Episode
July 8, 2025

New! Unidentified--Budd Hopkins and the Manhattan Alien Abduction

In this episode, we wrap with the sad end of John Mack's once-fine career, then dive deeply into the most "important" "alien" "abduction" that pioneering researcher Budd Hopkins ever covered. Yes, this is the story of a woman...

Listen to the Episode
June 24, 2025

New! Unidentified--John Mack's abduction theories fall apart

In which we review the downfall of a once-respected psychiatrist, as John Mack publishes his findings only to have them completely torn apart by a wide variety of critics. Worse, we learn how he was taken in by an undercover ...

Listen to the Episode
June 10, 2025

New! Unidentified--The Harvard psychiatrist who believed in abductions

In this episode, we wrap up the last bit of Strieber, before turning our attention to John Mack, a celebrated and respected psychiatrist who, late in his career, turned his attention to investigating, and then advocating for ...

Listen to the Episode
May 27, 2025

New! Unidentified--Lightning strikes versus alien abductions

Hearkening back to high school English class, we compare and contrast my and Whitley Strieber's unusual experiences. Also, we hear from my real-life parents, who do their best to recall what really happened with my lightning ...

Listen to the Episode
April 29, 2025

New! Unidentified--Christopher Walken dances with aliens

Whitley Strieber's abduction, and the film it inspired

Listen to the Episode
April 1, 2025

New! Unidentified--Close Encounters of the X-Files Kind

How the way we look at abductions changed between the 1970s and the 1990s

Listen to the Episode
Jan. 7, 2025

New! Unidentified--No ETs for Christmas

We're back for 2025. This episode, we wrap up the story of The Seekers, the failure of their 1950s UFO prophecy, and the book that made them famous. We also dive into the ways cognitive dissonance theory interacts with other ...

Listen to the Episode
Jan. 3, 2025

Encore: Upon a Red Horse, Part V

The last part of our encore presentation. hope you enjoyed it--see you next week. In which Fletcher slowly loses what matters most to him, secures his legend, and goes down, senselessly, in a hail of bullets. Full lyrics, cre...

Listen to the Episode